Another false assumption guiding the view that business ethics can’t be taught is the belief that one’s ethics are fully formed and unchangeable by the time one is old enough to enter college or a job. However, this is definitely not the case. Research has found that through a complex process of social interaction with peers, parents, and other significant persons, children and young adults develop in their ability to make ethical judgments. This development continues at least through young adulthood. In fact, young adults in their twenties and thirties who attend moral development educational programs have been found to advance in moral reasoning even more than younger individuals do.18 Given that most people enter professional education programs and corporations as young adults, the opportunity to influence their moral reasoning clearly exists.
Business
school students may need ethics training more than most because research has
shown they have ranked lower in moral reasoning than students in philosophy,
political science, law, medicine, and dentistry.19 Also, undergraduate business
students and those aiming for a business career were found to be more likely to
engage in academic cheating (test cheating, plagiarism, etc.) than were
students in other majors or those headed toward other careers.20 At a minimum,
professional ethics education can direct attention to the ambiguities and
ethical gray areas that are easily overlooked without it. Consider this comment
from a 27-year-old Harvard student after a required nine-session module in
decision making and ethical values at the beginning of the Harvard MBA program.
Before,
[when] I looked at a problem in the business world, I never consciously examined
the ethical issues in play. It was always subconscious and I hope that I
somewhat got it. But that [ethics] was never even a consideration. But now,
when I look at a problem, I have to look at the impact. I’m going to put in
this new ten-million-dollar project. What’s going to be the impact on the
people that live in the area and the environment. . . . It’s opened my mind up
on those things. It’s also made me more aware of situations where I might be
walking down the wrong path and getting in deeper and deeper, to where I can’t
pull back.
In
2004, Harvard’s MBA class of 1979 met for its 25-year reunion. The alumni gave
the dean a standing ovation when he said that a new required course on values and
leadership was his highest priority and then pledged to ‘‘live my life and lead
the school in a way that will earn your trust.’’22
It
should be clear from the above arguments that ethics can indeed be taught.
Ethical
behavior relies on more than good character. Although good upbringing may provide
a kind of moral compass that can help the individual determine the right direction
and then follow through on a decision to do the right thing, it’s certainly not
the only factor determining ethical conduct. In today’s highly complex
organizations, individuals need additional guidance. They can be trained to
recognize the ethical dilemmas that are likely to arise in their jobs; the
rules, laws, and norms that apply in that context; reasoning strategies that
can be used to arrive at the best ethical decision; and the complexities of
organizational life that can conflict with one’s desire to do the right thing.
For example, businesses that do defense-related work are expected to comply
with a multitude of laws and regulations that go far beyond what the average
person can be expected to know.
The
question of whether ethics should be
taught remains. Many still believe that ethics is a personal issue best left to
individuals. They believe that much like proselytizing about religion, teaching
ethics involves inappropriate efforts to impose certain values and control
behavior. But we believe that employers have a real responsibility to teach
employees what they need to know to recognize and deal with ethical issues they
are likely to face at work. Failing to help employees recognize the risks in
their jobs is like failing to teach a machinist how to operate a machine
safely. Both situations can result in harm, and that’s just poor management.
Similarly, we believe that, as business educators, we have a responsibility to
prepare you for the complex ethical issues you’re going to face and to help you
think about what you can do to lead others in an ethical direction.
0 comments:
Post a Comment